Close Menu
Beverly Hills Examiner

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    What's Hot

    State seeks to block Christa Pikes attorneys from inspecting execution drug

    November 19, 2026

    Here Are the 2026 National Book Awards Winners

    November 19, 2026

    Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella explains why he asked 60K employees to quit | TechCrunch

    November 19, 2026
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Beverly Hills Examiner
    • Home
    • US News
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Science
    • Technology
    • Lifestyle
    • Music
    • Television
    • Film
    • Books
    • Contact
      • About
      • Amazon Disclaimer
      • DMCA / Copyrights Disclaimer
      • Terms and Conditions
      • Privacy Policy
    Beverly Hills Examiner
    Home»Science»Is there really a conflict between General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics? – Experimental Frontiers, with Josh Mitteldorf
    Science

    Is there really a conflict between General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics? – Experimental Frontiers, with Josh Mitteldorf

    By AdminJanuary 6, 2024
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Reddit Telegram
    Is there really a conflict between General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics? – Experimental Frontiers, with Josh Mitteldorf

    [ad_1]

    The problem of combining General Relativity with Quantum Mechanics in a self-consistent theory is so difficult that it has defied the best minds in physics for 75 years. But this may not be necessary. We don’t actually know that General Relativity is correct.

    You have probably heard that the greatest problem confronting theoretical physics is that we have two incompatible theories. General Relativity is Einstein’s theory of gravity, and it applies in the realm of astronomy, where it has been validated. Quantum Mechanics is a theory of atoms and subatomic particles, and it has been validated in the realm of the very small. The problem is that these two theories both work well, but they are incompatible. Einstein spent the last years of his life trying to combine them, and the world’s smartest physicists have tried ever since without success.

    The natural thing to do would be to try experiments with quantum gravity, and use the results to home in on a theory. But no such experiments are feasible. The world’s biggest particle accelerator can reach energies of trillions of electron volts (10^12 eV). Quantum gravity effects are predicted to be discernable at about 10^28 eV. We would need a particle accelerator that is a million billion times bigger than what we’ve got. Of course, we have no idea how to construct such an accelerator, and if we built it using present technology, it would be the size of our galaxy.

    So, we’re at a loss to reconcile these two great theories, but we’re not at a loss to explain anything that we can actually observe. Our reason for believing that these two theories ought to be compatible comes from a faith in the Zeroth Law of Science, taken literally. GR and QM must be part of some self-consistent Grand Unified Theory because we have faith that the universe is built on mathematical foundations that are absolutely consistent, and that hold everywhere and forever.

    I was an undergraduate physics major in 1969, in my senior year, taking courses that were over my head because I was ambitious. I was privileged and cursed to receive my introduction to quantum mechanics from Julian Schwinger, a Nobel laureate, and co-inventor of quantum field theory. He left my head spinning three mornings a week.

    At the time, there were three classic tests of GR.

    1. First, light from a star bends as it passes by the sun. In fact, it bends twice as much as if you just used a naïve model of light as a particle (photon). Of course, you normally can’t photograph a star that’s right next to the sun, but during an eclipse, the sky becomes dark enough that stars right next to the sun become visible. In 1919, Arthur Edington traveled to West Africa explicitly to be in the path of a total eclipse, where he could take a photograph that tested Einstein’s new General Theory of Relativity. The result vindicated Einstein, and the world applauded.
    2. Second, the orbits of all planets are not exactly circular. According to Newtonian gravity, the orbit should be an ellipse, fixed in space. But with Einstein’s corrections, the ellipse itself rotates so that the point of the ellipse moves a little further around the sun with each pass through the orbit.  Mercury moves through the orbit in 88 days, but the orbit takes 23,000 years to complete a rotation around the sun. This is called “precession of the perihelion”, and Einstein’s prediction for the rate of precession is thought to be only part of the story. The precession is also driven in the same direction by the sun’s shape, which is slightly oblate, not exactly spherical. It’s far the most complicated calculation of the three, but results are said to vindicate Einstein.

    3. Third is a gravitational redshift. Light that is rising out of a gravitational field loses energy and becomes redder as a result. If you shine a laser straight up from the first floor of the Physics Dept building at Harvard and intercept the light on the fourth floor with an instrument very sensitive to wavelength, you will find that the wavelength is very slightly longer (the color is very slightly redder) on the 4th floor than it was on the 1st floor. This experiment won a Nobel prize for my my Freshman physics professor, Robert Pound.

    All the physics students in Dr Schwinger’s class knew of these three tests. They’re legendary. Imagine our amazement when Dr Schwinger spent three lectures calculating predictions for these three experiments from his own quantum theory of the graviton.

    All three quantum computations agreed with Einstein’s prediction from General Relativity.

    What could this mean? Where’s the conflict between QM and GR? Where’s the problem that the best minds in physics have been obsessing over for the last 75 years?

    Answer: For situations that are “close to” Newtonian, GR and QM give the same answer.

    Gravity is so weak that the only measurements that we can make are far less precise than measurements in chemistry or electromagnetism or nuclear physics. In most everyday and astronomical applications, the predictions of GR and Newtonian gravity are so close that we can’t tell them apart. And even in the case of these three classic “tests of general relativity”, the difference between GR and Newtonian is tiny. In such cases, GR predicts the same size departure from Newtonian as QM, so in practice the QM theory is perfectly adequate, and we don’t really need GR.

    It’s only in the vicinity of a black hole or a neutron star that the difference between GR and Newtonian physics becomes sizable. We certainly do see neutron stars and black holes in the sky, but we can’t use them to verify the GR predictions because we don’t know precisely what we are looking at. We don’t have an independent way to measure the mass of the NS or BH. So, in practice, what astronomers do is to assume that GR is correct and calculate backwards from their observations to make inferences about the BH or the NS.

    There’s a technique from physics, as old as Newton, by which you can frequently solve a difficult problem approximately. It’s called ‘perturbation theory.’

    1. Find a simple version of the same problem
    2. Solve the simple version
    3. Solve an equation for how much the answer changes when you move away from the simple problem in the direction of the difficult problem
    4. Determine by how much your parameters differ from the simple version and use #3 to move along a straight line away from the simple answer by the appropriate amount.
    5. If you want a better answer you can repeat the process in #3 and analyze the correction to your correction. This is like moving away from the simple solution along a parabola instead of a straight line.

    In the case of Newtonian gravity and Einstein’s GR, the Newtonian answer is easy to calculate, and the GR calculation is usually very difficult — way beyond computation for general cases with odd geometries. The Newtonian answer is the one you would get if you were very far away from a gravitating star or planet.

    How big is the difference between the (simple) Newtonian answer and the (hard to calculate) GR answer? The answer is that it is proportional to the ratio of the radius of a hypothetical black hole to the radius at which you’re working.

    For example, think about light passing by the sun for Eddington’s 1919 test of GR. If the sun were a black hole, it would have a radius of about 3 Km. The sun’s actual radius, where the starlight passes by the sun during an eclipse, is 700,000 Km. This tells you that the answer from Newtonian gravity and the answer from GR differ by about 3:700,000 or one part in 200,000.

    The punch line, the point that I am aiming for, is that all three of the observed confirmations of Einstein’s General Relativity are like this. The differences from Newtonian gravity are very tiny, and it takes special circumstances and delicate measurements to distinguish the relativistic correction to Newtonian gravity.

    Crucially: the standard formula from quantum field theory
    of gravitons gives the same answer as GR in these cases.

    So all the fuss about needing a way to reconcile quantum field theory with GR is just theoretical. There is no conflict in practice for any quantities that we are able to observe or measure.

    Certainly there have been other applications of GR since I went to school in the 1960s. Gravitational waves have been observed, but we don’t know where they came from, so can’t use them to distinguish different theories of gravity.

    GR is used to make cosmological calculations, for example the age of our universe and the evolution of the universe since the Big Bang. But these calculations assume that GR is true. They are not a test of whether GR is true.

    Hawking radiation is a result of GR in the quantum realm, but once again, calculations of Hawking radiation are rooted in theory. Hawking radiation has never been observed in practice.

    Gravitational lensing is another GR effect which is used to interpret observations in the sky. When we see a distant galaxy behind a nearby galaxy, sometimes the image is fractured and we see multiple copies of the rear galaxy on opposite sides of the galaxy in front. Or the image of the rear galaxy can be spread out to appear as a ring around the front galaxy.

    Gravitational Lensing | ESA/Hubble | ESA/Hubble

    But since we don’t know the mass or position of the close galaxy, no quantitative conclusions can be drawn from gravitational lens observations.

    The most stringent test by far is the Global Positioning System, GPS, that we use when we’re driving, and that everyone from pilots to backpackers counts on as well. The GPS system works by comparing the time that it takes a radio signal to reach you from several different satellites. Each satellite is broadcasting the exact time, accurate to a billionth of a second, and the GPS chip in your cell phone picks up three or more time readings that differ from one another very slightly because of the time that it takes the signal to reach you from each of them. It is from these differences that the chip calculates how far you are from each of the satellites, and from this can calculate where you are on the earth’s surface.

    The clocks on these satellites run slightly faster than our clocks on earth because the earth’s gravitational field is weaker up there. The difference is very tiny, but large enough that it has to be factored into the calculation in order for the chip to render your position accurately.

    This is a GR correction to Newtonian gravity, and it is the best indication that we have that GR actually works — better than the Edington eclipse measurement or the Pound-Rebka experiment or the precession of Mercury. But still, the GR correction is very small, and so it remains in the regime where quantum field theory and GR give the same answer.

    Conclusion: As far as we know, quantum field theory of gravitons gives the right answer for everything about gravity that we can actually measure. We’ve tried like the devil to reconcile GR with QFT, without success so far. But it may be that we don’t need to reconcile them. It may be that QFT is all we need.

    Physicists love GR because it is built on an elegant mathematical foundation. Simple ideas generate immensely complex equations, and those equations seem to work. This is a physicist’s idea of heaven.

    Einstein was interviewed after Eddington verified his General Relativity in 1919. Reportedly, when asked what his reaction would have been if Eddington’s measurements had not supported his predictions, Einstein replied:

    “To tell you the truth, I would have been sorry for the dear Lord—the theory is correct.”

    Einstein’s General Relativity is the most beautiful theory that anyone has ever come up with, but that doesn’t oblige Nature to live by Einstein’s rules.

    [ad_2]

    Original Source Link

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Reddit Telegram
    Previous ArticleSundance Film Fest Reveals Beyond Film Lineup, Speakers and Programming – The Hollywood Reporter
    Next Article Why Everyone Is Obsessed With the Kid Who Beat ‘Tetris’

    RELATED POSTS

    Voyager 1 Beat the Odds and Is Still Working a Light-Day Away From Earth

    November 18, 2026

    The Dark Side of the Moon Was the Brightest Part of 2026

    November 17, 2026

    Heres What We Know About the X-70 Fractal, NASAs Experimental New Plane

    November 10, 2026

    Scientists May Have Discovered a Massive Starless Galaxy

    November 9, 2026

    These Robotic Arms Are Powered by Algae. Watch How They Move

    November 9, 2026

    A 55-Year-Old Math Problem Was Solved—This Time by Humans

    November 8, 2026
    latest posts

    State seeks to block Christa Pikes attorneys from inspecting execution drug

    Tennessee is seeking to block Christa Pike’s attorneys from accessing the lethal injection drug used…

    Here Are the 2026 National Book Awards Winners

    November 19, 2026

    Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella explains why he asked 60K employees to quit | TechCrunch

    November 19, 2026

    Waxahatchee Is Hosting a Songwriting Workshop

    November 18, 2026

    More banks says customers using AI agents are on their own — even if they get hacked | TechCrunch

    November 18, 2026

    Esosa Gabrielle Delivers a Powerful Musical Confession with Her Stunning New Single “Guilty”

    November 18, 2026

    Episode 3: Wild Horse Nine and Possible Love

    November 18, 2026
    Categories
    • Books (1,616)
    • Business (6,521)
    • Cover Story (17)
    • Film (6,455)
    • Lifestyle (4,498)
    • Music (6,531)
    • Politics (6,506)
    • Science (5,861)
    • Technology (6,458)
    • Television (6,153)
    • Uncategorized (3)
    • US News (6,505)
    popular posts

    Yahoo removes DEI pages from its website

    [ad_1] Tech company Yahoo has removed several pages and other sections from its corporate website…

    To Life: Abortion Access Allowed Us to Have a Happy, Healthy Family

    July 18, 2022

    ‘Yellowstone’ Star Kevin Costner’s Divorce Takes Nasty Turn As Wife Refuses To Move Out Of Home

    June 15, 2023

    “Enough is Enough!” – Kamala Harris Calls For Gun Control Following Deadly Mass Shooting at Texas Elementary School (VIDEO)

    May 25, 2022
    Archives
    Browse By Category
    • Books (1,616)
    • Business (6,521)
    • Cover Story (17)
    • Film (6,455)
    • Lifestyle (4,498)
    • Music (6,531)
    • Politics (6,506)
    • Science (5,861)
    • Technology (6,458)
    • Television (6,153)
    • Uncategorized (3)
    • US News (6,505)
    About Us

    We are a creativity led international team with a digital soul. Our work is a custom built by the storytellers and strategists with a flair for exploiting the latest advancements in media and technology.

    Most of all, we stand behind our ideas and believe in creativity as the most powerful force in business.

    What makes us Different

    We care. We collaborate. We do great work. And we do it with a smile, because we’re pretty damn excited to do what we do. If you would like details on what else we can do visit out Contact page.

    Our Picks

    Esosa Gabrielle Delivers a Powerful Musical Confession with Her Stunning New Single “Guilty”

    November 18, 2026

    Episode 3: Wild Horse Nine and Possible Love

    November 18, 2026

    Immigration arrests go on unabated despite Trumps misgivings after the GOPs midterm wipeout

    November 18, 2026
    © 2026 Beverly Hills Examiner. All rights reserved. All articles, images, product names, logos, and brands are property of their respective owners. All company, product and service names used in this website are for identification purposes only. Use of these names, logos, and brands does not imply endorsement unless specified. By using this site, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
    Cookie SettingsAccept All
    Manage consent

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled
    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously.
    CookieDurationDescription
    cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics".
    cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional11 monthsThe cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
    cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".
    cookielawinfo-checkbox-others11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other.
    cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance".
    viewed_cookie_policy11 monthsThe cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data.
    Functional
    Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
    Performance
    Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
    Analytics
    Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
    Advertisement
    Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
    Others
    Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
    SAVE & ACCEPT